News & Blogs Award Shows Facts & Dates Galleries Forums    
SEARCH:
Search Entire Site Search Awards Database
AWARDS DATABASE
All of the winners, all of the nominees, all of the awards shows.
Up Next
Oct. 13-16
• ShowEast

Oct. 17-29
• Viennale 2008 - Vienna International Film Festival


Guilds vs. Globes
Guilds vs. Globes: The Producers Guild noms pretty much put the nail in the coffin for the two big Golden Globe Best Picture winners, “Sweeney Todd” (Comedy or Musical) and “Atonement” (Drama), at least as far as the Academy is concerned.
(Focus Features / DreamWorks)

Recent Columns


Pete Hammond is film critic for Maxim Magazine and Maximonline.com. He contributes to "Leonard Maltin's Movie Guide" and hosts Q&A screenings with top Oscar contenders for KCET Cinema Series and Variety. He appears frequently on TV as a pop-culture pundit and has been a producer for "Entertainment Tonight," "Extra," "Access Hollywood" and AMC - American Movie Classics network. Pete's "Note on a Season" column appears weekly on Thursdays exclusively on TheEnvelope.com.
Notes on a Season

The plot for the season thickens

A Global disaster will be followed by BAFTAs, and then, the Big Kahuna.
By Pete Hammond
January 14, 2008
In the wake of the disaster known as the 65th Annual Golden Globe Awards comes the last of the key guild indicators today, the list of five nominees for the top award of the Producers Guild Of America.

The biggest omission from what the rest of the major Guilds (WGA, DGA, SAG) have been doing so far is no producer love for "Into The Wild."

Otherwise the PGA's choices -- "No Country For Old Men," "The Diving Bell And The Butterfly" (co-produced by former PGA prexy Kathleen Kennedy), "There Will Be Blood," "Juno" and "Michael Clayton" -- are consistent with the other Guilds and would seem to indicate they are also the likely five nominees for Oscar's best picture honor roll.

Actually, with "Into The Wild" still a very viable shot, we have a situation of six films locked for five slots. Someone is going to be terribly disappointed come January 22nd.

The PGA list also effectively put the nail in the coffin for the two big Golden Globe best picture winners, "Sweeney Todd" (comedy or musical) and "Atonement" (drama), at least as far as the Academy is concerned.

Neither has received a single mention from the four major guilds nor are they scoring well in private and informal polling of Oscar voters over the last week (but as Hillary Clinton likes to say, 'Who cares about polls anyway?'). The Globes winners will have no impact on the Oscar race because Academy ballots were due in on Saturday.

By the way, several Academy voters were seen personally dropping off their ballots at Price Waterhouse's downtown headquarters on Saturday before the 5pm deadline. More voters than usual this year seemed to wait until the last possible moment to get their ballots in.

At any rate, for the acclaimed "Atonement" in particular, the Golden Globe win was at least a big psychological boost after what must have been a rather frustrating couple of weeks of being passed over by the Guilds. Director Joe Wright was so happy he said he was going skinny-dipping in his hotel pool.

Interestingly ,1996 Globe drama winner, "The English Patient" had seven nominations, same number as "Atonement," and both won the exact same two awards (music score was the other). "English Patient" went on to win nine Oscars including best picture but, unlike "Atonement" this year, it was a player in all the guild races.

The Guild's shut-out of the two Globes faves does present a fascinating and potentially unprecedented situation. Only once in its sixty-five-year history, at least in any records that the organization has kept, has there been a year (1955) when at least one of the Globe best picture winners (drama or variations of comedy or musical) did not go on to be nominated in the Oscar best picture category.

With newly crowned Globe champs "Sweeney" and "Atonement" seemingly on the bubble, or even the < i>ropes as far as their best picture Oscar chances stand, at the moment this could be the first year since '55 that the Hollywood Foreign Press truly has winners completely foreign to the Academy's nominee list.

Along with the fact that none of the HFPA's (six) best picture choices in the last three years matched the Academy's ultimate winner, it could be damaging to their proud reputation as a strong bellwether for Oscar.

Add this potential embarrassment to their strike-gutted awards ceremony this year (we're getting to that shortly) and this just might be a year the HFPA would like to forget.

Their choices in the acting categories however, Daniel Day-Lewis, Johnny Depp, Javier Bardem, Julie Christie, Marion Cotillard and Cate Blanchett were spot-on and all would seem to be locks for Oscar nods.

That is good news for the HFPA since they are also contending with the aggressive moves being made by the Broadcast Critics Association and their Critics Choice Awards which were unaffected by the strike and chose front runner "No Country For Old Men" as their best picture after being one of the few groups last year to mirror the Academy's choice of "The Departed."



Local Ads